How to make simple syrup with xylitol
Looking for a sugar-free syrup recipe that tastes like the real thing?
This simple sugar-free syrup is really easy to make and it tastes just like regular syrup.
So get ready to sweeten your iced tea, coffee or any other beverage of your choice with this keto-friendly syrup!
What do you use simple syrup for?
Simple syrup is a liquid sweetener made by dissolving sugar in water.
It has a slightly viscous texture and it easily dissolves in cold drinks, so it’s often used to sweeten cocktails and chilled drinks, like iced tea or frappes.
Can you make simple syrup without sugar?
Yes, you can use sugar-free sweeteners to make an outstanding simple syrup: it tastes like the regular version, but without all that empty calories.
In this recipe you’ll learn how to make a sugar-free simple syrup with xylitol, which is a low-carb sugar alcohol.
I’ve also tried making it with erythriol (one of my favorites sugar alternatives), but my erythriol simple syrup still crystallizes, so I will just share the xylitol version for now.
On the other side, while I haven’t tried it, it looks like you can replace the xylitol for allulose to make this simple syrup (allulose has not been approved in the European Union, where I live, yet).
This post may contain affiliate links. This means, if you make a purchase through one of these links, I may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Here you can read my affiliate disclosure.
You only need 3 ingredients to make this keto-friendly syrup – you may even only use only 2, but the last optional ingredient is my opinion the “magic touch”.
For more details about each ingredient, keep reading bellow.
Just a few ingredients
WATER – there is not much to say about this ingredient.
You may use regular tap water (of course, as long as it’s drinkable); in my experience, there is no special need for distilled water or store bought water.
XYLITOL – this sugar alcohol, also known as birch sugar, is naturally found in many plants.
Birch sugar tastes as sweet as regular sugar but it doesn’t cause cavities.
Xylitol is also low-carbohydrate and keto-friendly.
You can find xylitol in granulated form in most food stores or online.
Just be aware that xylitol it’s not safe for pets; if you prefer to skip the xylitol for this reason, it looks like you may want to replace it for allulose.
XANTHAN GUM – this ingredient is a thickener and emulsifier.
It’s often used in gluten-free baking and it helps to prevent sugar crystallization.
While this ingredient is optional, I strongly recommend using it; xanthan gum will give your syrup a viscous, thicker consistency and it will prevent the xylitol become gritty.
You can find xanthan gum in the baking aisle of some supermarkets or online.
Interestingly, although the name may sound artificial and therefore unhealthy, xantham gum may actually provide some interesting dietary benefits.
How to make sugar-free simple syrup
The great thing about this sugar-free syrup recipe is that it only takes a few minutes to make and then you’ll have enough amount to make drinks with it for a while.
Here’s how to make sugar-free simple syrup using xylitol:
How to make sugar-free simple syrup (with xylitol)
- Dissolve the xylitol
Place the xylitol in a small saucepan, pour carefully the water and simmer.
- Let cool down a little
Take off heat when the xylitol has dissolved completely.
IMPORTANT: wait until the syrup has cooled down to room temperature before going to the next step (if you add the xanthan gum while the syrup is still warm, it clumps).
- Mix the xanthan gum
Add the xanthan gum and blend until the xanthan is evenly distributed (I use the mixer accessory to whip cream).
The syrup will likely get a cloudy look but without noticeable big chunks of xantan gum.
Tricks to make sugar-free syrup that doesn’t crystallize
- Add xanthan gum after removing the saucepan from the heat:
Xanthan gum is known to prevent crystallization, but it also clumps very easily. To prevent it, don’t add it to the saucepan: wait instead until the syrup has cooled down a bit before adding it.
- Wait 24 hours before storing the simple syrup in the fridge:
I’ve read that this allows the ingredients to “set” and it make less likely that the xylitol crystallize. I can’t confirm if this is true because I haven’t tried putting the simple syrup in the fridge right away, but when letting the simple syrup one day in room temperature before refrigerating, it didn’t crystallize, so it may be worth a try. (Please tell me in the comments bellow your experience if you’ve put the syrup in the fridge from the beginning).
- Use xylitol (or allulose) instead of erythriol:
Erythritol is another sugar alcohol that has very similar properties to xylitol but until now, when I tried making a simple syrup with erythritol, it crystallized sooner or later.
Who knows, maybe with more tweaking I’ll be able to make an erythritol simple syrup that doesn’t crystallize (and be sure that I will happily share the recipe then!)
How to store homemade xylitol syrup
Xylitol has a similar shelf life as regular sugar, and regular syrup made from xylitol has also a similar shelf life than regular homemade simple syrup.
Sugar free xylitol may be stored in a airtight, sterile and closed container for up to 1 month in the fridge.
Some people say that simple syrup may last for up to several months in the fridge but I like to play it safe and use it within one month.
You can also freeze sugar-free simple syrup.
If you freeze simple syrup, I recommend doing it in small measured portions, so you can easily thaw and use only what you need.
Ideas to use this sugar-free syrup
You may use this xylitol simple syrup for any purpose you would use regular sugar syrup.
Here are a few ideas:
- To sweeten iced tea, coffee or any other beverage of your choice
- To make cocktails and mocktails (it’s a great sugar-free option for mojitos!)
- As a pancake syrup or waffle syrup
Sugar-free simple syrup will last for up to one month when stored properly in the fridge (in a closed, airtight, clean container).
Yes, you can make this recipe without xanthan gum, but the texture and consistency of your syrup may be different.
Yes, as long as you add xantan gum, this xylitol syrup has a very similar viscosity and taste as Starbucks´ simple syrup.
Easy sugar-free simple syrup recipe
- Small saucepan
- whisker or blender
- Put xylitol in a small saucepan, add the water carefully and simmer.
- When the xylitol has dissolved completely, take off the heat.Pour the syrup into a blender glass or a blend resistant container. Let the syrup cool down a little before adding the xanthan gum (this is to prevent clumping).
- Add the xantan gum and blend until the xantan is evenly distributed (I use the accessories to whip cream with a hand mixer). The syrup will likely get a cloudy look but without noticeable chunks of xantan gum.
- Put in a clean, airtight container and let it rest for 24 hours at room temperature. After that, store it in the fridge and use within a month.
- A word of caution – Xylitol is toxic for dogs
- What to replace xylitol with – it looks like you may replace the xylitol in this recipe 1:1 for allulose
As you’ve seen, making your own sugar-free version of simple syrup is super easy!
Using this simple syrup you’ll be able to make any kind of drink you like keto-friendly.
And also has the consistency of Starbucks simple syrup!
If you are looking for other recipes to make Starbucks copycats in a keto-friendlier way, be sure to check how to make sugar-free pumpkin spice syrup.
And for other tricks to sweeten your tea (or other drinks) without using sugar, be sure to read this super comprehensive list of best sugar-alternatives to sweeten tea.